RankedCooking & Recipes

Best Ways to Cook a Thanksgiving Turkey (Ranked by Method)

US Thanksgiving is Thursday, Nov 26, 2026 (Canada's was Oct 12). Methods ranked on how reliably they give juicy breast and done thighs, then cost, time and kit, for a first-timer or a seasoned host. Safety figures come only from government sources: USDA/CDC say 165F (74C) for poultry; Health Canada says 82C (180F) for whole birds and 74C (165F) for pieces and stuffing. Use a thermometer.

A community-ranked list on FindBest — currently in the creator's order; no member votes yet. Votes change the order: when members vote, the list is ordered by their votes. How ranking works.

TTheo Marchetti

10 entriesAdded Oct 21, 2026

The podium

— the creator's order — no votes yet

10 entries

Sort

Dry brine, then roast

The best return on effort. Salt the bird all over a day or more ahead and leave it uncovered in the fridge; the skin dries and the meat is seasoned through. Then roast as normal. Butterball's chart puts a 10-18 lb unstuffed bird at about 3-3.5 hours at 325F. Check the label first: many supermarket birds are already injected with a salt solution, and salting those again makes them too salty.

4 pros · 3 cons

Spatchcock (butterflied) roast

Cut out the backbone with poultry shears, press the bird flat and roast it on a sheet pan at high heat. Breast and legs are now level, so they finish close together and the whole bird cooks much faster than a whole roast. It is the best fix for dry breast. Costs: strong shears, a big sheet pan, and losing the Norman Rockwell carving moment. Go by the thermometer, not a clock.

4 pros · 3 cons

Roast in parts (breast roasted, legs braised)

Break the bird down before it goes in: roast the breast on the bone, and braise the legs and thighs low and slow in stock until tender. Each part gets the treatment it needs, and Health Canada's pieces figure (74C/165F) applies instead of the whole-bird 82C. You lose the whole bird at the table but gain the best dark meat of any method here, plus a ready-made gravy base.

4 pros · 3 cons

Classic whole roast at 325F

The default for a reason: it works in any oven and needs nothing special. Butterball's published times for an unstuffed bird at 325F are about 2.5-3 hours for 7-10 lb, 3-3.5 hours for 10-18 lb and 3.5-4 hours for 18-22 lb. Tent the breast with foil about two-thirds of the way through and rest it 15 minutes. The weak point: the breast is done before the thighs.

4 pros · 3 cons

Smoked

The flavour winner if you already own a smoker. Butterball's guidance: hold a water smoker around 250F and expect 4-8 hours for an 8-12 lb bird or 6-10 hours for 12-18 lb; an electric smoker at 225F runs 8-12 hours. Keep it to 18 lb or under. The skin goes rubbery unless you finish it hot, and the timing is a moving target.

3 pros · 3 cons

Deep-fried

The fastest whole-bird method, and the most dangerous. Butterball's directions: oil at 375F, about 3-4 minutes per pound, outdoors on flat ground well away from the house, garage and wooden decks, never unattended. The turkey must be fully thawed and patted dry. Measure the oil line with water first so the pot doesn't overflow. Crisp skin, juicy meat, real fire risk.

3 pros · 3 cons

Grilled (indirect heat, kettle or gas)

A good way to free the oven when you have a covered grill but no smoker. Butterball's method uses indirect heat over a drip pan, around 350F on gas, and gives 2-3 hours for a 10-16 lb bird; it stays under 16 lb and says never stuff a grilled turkey. Charcoal needs topping up every 45-60 minutes, so someone has to stay outside with it.

3 pros · 3 cons

Wet brine, then roast

Submerging the bird in salt water overnight does make it juicier, but it is a lot of hassle: you need a food-safe container or brining bag that fits in the fridge, the turkey must be fully thawed, and a cooked brine has to be cooled first. The meat can turn spongy and the skin is harder to crisp than with a dry brine. Same warning: don't brine a pre-brined or enhanced bird.

3 pros · 3 cons

Sous vide in parts, then sear

Bag the breast and legs separately, cook them in a precisely held water bath, then sear or roast to crisp the skin. You get edge-to-edge even meat and can do it days ahead. The catch: low-temperature schedules rely on time to make meat safe and are not in USDA or Health Canada's charts, which give single temperatures. If you want to stay inside those, take the parts to 74C/165F.

3 pros · 3 cons

Turkey breast only (small gatherings)

For four to six people a whole bird is mostly leftovers. A bone-in breast roasts in a fraction of the time, fits a smaller pan, and avoids the breast-versus-thigh problem entirely because there is no thigh. Health Canada treats it as a piece, so 74C (165F) is the target. Downsides: dark-meat fans go without, and you get less carcass for stock.

3 pros · 3 cons

Missing something?

Suggest an entry. The FindBest editors check every suggestion against a source before it goes on the list, and you will see what happened to it here.

Discussions

No discussions on this list yet.

Related lists· more in Cooking & Recipes

See all in Cooking & Recipes